• Home
  • |
  • Blog
  • |
  • Selling Handmade Products Online: Pros and Cons

Selling Handmade Products Online: Pros and Cons

By admin

March 21, 2025

diy, selling, woodworking cnc

Click on video above or podcast below this text.

Podcast -->

Thinking of Going Online? My Thoughts After Hearing This Podcast

Hey folks, Paul here from Dusty Workbench. You know, lately, it feels like every time I'm scrolling through the 'gram or even just popping down to the local market, I'm seeing more and more amazing handmade businesses popping up. It's inspiring stuff!

It got me thinking, and it seems like a lot of other makers are probably wondering the same thing I am: should I take my handmade business online? It's a big question, right? Well, recently, I even made a video about it – "7 Key Pros and Cons of Taking Your Handmade Business Online" – just kind of laying out my initial thoughts and research.

And get this, there's even a podcast out there that did a deep dive into my video! I was pretty stoked to hear their take on everything, and it definitely got the wheels turning even more. So, I wanted to share some of my thoughts after listening in.

The Double-Edged Sword: Reach vs. Competition

One of the first things they talked about, and it's a big one, is the sheer reach you get online. I mean, it's mind-blowing to think about the potential customer base. You're not just limited to folks who can physically come to your market stall anymore. You could be reaching people all over the country, even the world! That's a huge potential for growth.

But, as they rightly pointed out, with that massive audience comes a ton of competition. It feels like everyone and their dog is selling something online these days, doesn't it? So, just having a nice website or an Etsy shop isn't enough. You really have to figure out how to stand out from the crowd and get those eyeballs on your creations. That's definitely something I'm still trying to wrap my head around.

Click, Buy, Ship... But How Do They Find You?

Now, when it comes to the actual selling process, going online seems a lot more streamlined. No more standing on your feet all day making small talk (though I do enjoy meeting folks!). It's more about good descriptions, great photos, and then the customer just clicks "buy." Easy peasy, right? But the real kicker is getting those customers to your shop in the first place. That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? How do you get those initial sales and then keep people coming back for more?

The Highs and Lows of Online Validation

Something that really resonated with me from the podcast was the discussion about confidence. They mentioned how those first few online sales and positive reviews can be such a huge boost. And it's true! You pour so much of yourself into your handmade work, and to have someone out there appreciate it enough to buy it? That's a fantastic feeling. But, they also brought up the flip side: negative reviews. The internet can be a harsh place, and you have to be prepared for that possibility. Though, as they wisely said, even negative feedback can be valuable if you look at it the right way – a chance to learn and improve.

Data-Driven Decisions vs. Creative Fulfillment

The podcast folks also called online selling "market research on steroids," and I thought that was spot on. You get almost instant feedback on what's selling well, what people are looking at. It's like having a real-time data stream. Pretty powerful stuff! But, they also cautioned against just chasing trends and potentially losing that creative spark that got you started in the first place. It's all about finding that balance.

Profit Potential vs. The Price of Going Online

Let's talk about the green stuff – profit margins. The potential is there to increase them, especially if you can really nail down what's selling and streamline your production. But, and this is a big but, there are a whole new set of expenses to consider: website fees, shop fees, advertising, shipping costs, packaging... the list goes on. You really have to be on top of your finances to make sure you're actually making a profit.

Bigger Income, Bigger To-Do List

The podcast also touched on the earning potential online, and yeah, the sky's the limit when you have access to a global market. But, that also comes with a significant increase in workload. If you're suddenly getting ten times the orders, you have to be able to fulfill them without disappointing customers. It's about being realistic about your capacity.

Connecting with Your Audience, Serving Their Needs

Beyond the sales, going online also opens up opportunities for building your brand and connecting directly with your customers. You can tell your story, share your process, and really build a community. But, with more customers comes more customer service. You'll be answering more questions, dealing with issues, and that can become a whole job in itself.

New Skills on the Horizon

Finally, one of the things I'm actually most excited about is the chance to learn new skills. Setting up an online shop forces you to dive into website stuff, marketing, social media – all sorts of things I'm still figuring out! It's a constant learning curve, but there are so many resources out there, or you can always outsource if it's not your cup of tea.

My Final Thoughts (For Now)... What About You?

So, yeah, listening to that podcast really reinforced a lot of my own thoughts and brought up some new things to consider. There's no easy answer to whether taking your handmade business online is the right move. It really depends on your individual situation, your skills, and your goals.

For me, I'm still in that exploration phase. What about you? If you're a fellow maker thinking about taking the plunge online, what aspects are you most excited about? And what are you most hesitant about? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments below! Maybe we can all figure this out together.

Thanks for stopping by the workbench today!

– Paul from Dusty Workbench

About the author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}